Three and a half years ago, The New York Times Magazine published The 1619 Project. It argued that 1619, the year the first slave ship is widely believed to have arrived in what is now the U.S., was as foundational to America as the year 1776, and that the legacy of chattel slavery still shapes our society. Essays from historians, scholars and others covered issues including capitalism, criminal justice and music, and sparked a national debate about race and history that is still raging.
Today, “The 1619 Project” premieres as a documentary series on Hulu. I spoke to The 1619 Project’s creator, Nikole Hannah-Jones, about what went into making the documentary and how the events of the past few years like the pandemic and racial justice protests shaped it.
German: American slavery ended generations ago, but one of the project’s arguments was that slavery’s legacy is still very much with us. Where do you see that most clearly?
Nikole: Every episode in the documentary is about modern America. It is following and it’s taking on some institution or aspect of modern American life and then showing how slavery has shaped that institution.
There’s a theme throughout the series: Black people suffer the most from the legacy of slavery, but most Americans suffer from it to some degree.
In one episode, we talk about how capitalism in the United States was shaped largely by chattel slavery and the exploitation of labor, even when workers are paid. And it hurts all of us because we have accepted inequalities in the United States, particularly among workers, no matter their race. We follow the effort to unionize Amazon facilities on Staten Island and in Alabama, where workers are organizing to address those disparities.
One way I’ve heard experts describe this is that politicians and other elites have used racist language and policies to divide white working-class and Black working-class people who would otherwise share a common cause. Is that what you’re speaking to?
Yes. An expert, historian Robin D.G. Kelley, talks in the capitalism episode about how the modern ideology around race was created to divide white laborers — like indentured servants — from enslaved Black people and Black people overall. The white, landed elite was exploiting all of these people.
By creating race and giving white people this honorary status and certain legal and societal rights, that was an effective way to divide those who were being exploited from one another.
That has effects today. We know Black people are more likely to be unemployed and more likely to live in poverty. But the American worker overall, no matter their race, is generally doing worse than those in other Western industrialized countries.
Who’s the most interesting person you interviewed for this?
One who stuck out is MacArthur Cotton, who was a member of the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee, or S.N.C.C., a student-led civil rights organization in the 1960s. He dropped out of college to fight to democratize America. He goes to prison for trying to register voters, where he was tortured — strung up by his wrists until he defecated on himself. He said the only thing that saved his life was that there was a group visiting the prison that day. I got emotional hearing that story and said, “I’m sorry that you had to go through that.” And he was like, “Don’t be sorry. This is what we had to do.”
Though The 1619 Project got a positive reception when The Times published it, it also became a political flash point. Conservative politicians have criticized it, and some states have banned it from curriculums. Why do you think that is?
The reason The 1619 Project needed to exist in the first place is because we have not, as a nation, wanted to grapple with this issue. For those who believe in American exceptionalism, they saw The 1619 Project as a direct challenge to that. Telling histories this way — centering slavery, centering marginalized people — has always been contested.
I think that is because it is very hard to buy into the notion of American exceptionalism and then deal with the history of Black people in this country.
Beyond that response, a lot has happened since The 1619 Project came out — Covid, the 2020 protests about police brutality and the Jan. 6 riot, to name a few events. Have they changed your thinking about the project?
A lot of it has confirmed and affirmed the thesis. We are still struggling with this founding paradox and which type of country we are going to be and who has the right to be part of “we the people” and determine our self-governance.
Many Americans want to understand: How does George Floyd happen? How does the Jan. 6 insurrection happen in this country? They feel they have not been equipped with the history they need to grapple with the through line in all these events. That is why this project exists.
What was different about doing this project for TV versus doing it for a magazine or book?
Well, I spent my entire life in print. It was my collaborators — Roger Ross Williams, who’s an executive producer; Shoshana Guy, the showrunner; and all the other producers who worked with me to map out how to translate this to television. The essays are dense.
I can take as long as I want to read a complicated passage when I’m reading something. But on TV, you have to take it in all at once. So there was a lot of figuring out: How do we translate all of this to a visual medium? Where do we film? How much voice-over? How much action?
I didn’t go into it with the hubris that I knew how to do this. I knew I had to rely on the experts in making television.
Related: Watch “The 1619 Project” on Hulu and read the essays.
THE LATEST NEWS
Politics
Other Big Stories
-
The trial of Alex Murdaugh, a former lawyer charged with murdering his wife and son, had a dramatic start as prosecutors presented new evidence.
-
“I can’t understand so much hate”: This week’s mass shooting in Half Moon Bay, Calif., has shaken its immigrant community.
-
On the day a 6-year-old shot his teacher in Virginia, school officials received three warnings that the boy might have had a gun, a lawyer for the teacher said.
-
As egg prices skyrocket, more people are trying to bring them across the U.S. border with Mexico.
-
Now that Splash Mountain, the popular ride at Walt Disney World, has closed for good, superfans are selling what they say is its water.
Opinions
Weaponizing identity politics saps progressive power, Maurice Mitchell argues on “First Person.”
Mass shootings are a symptom of another pressing societal problem: deaths of despair, Jillian Peterson and James Densley write.
The Casio G-Shock: On the durable watch’s 40th anniversary, visit a factory that makes it.
Tech fix: Think twice before you give out your email address.
Quiz: What are these apes trying to say?
Well: You’re never too old for yoga.
Advice from Wirecutter: When it comes to bedding, nothing beats a fluffy comforter.
Lives Lived: As a domestic servant in South Africa, Myrtle Witbooi experienced the inequities of servitude firsthand. As an activist, she helped lead national and international unions to address them. She died at 75.
SPORTS NEWS FROM THE ATHLETIC
Potential trade discussions: Aaron Rodgers hasn’t decided his football future, but if he plans to play somewhere other than Green Bay next year, the Jets should be first in line.
The next Brock Purdy? N.F.L. teams will try to capture the same luck as San Francisco did when picking Purdy in last year’s draft. The Athletic’s Andy Staples identified candidates.
The difficulty of nuance
The Resistance Museum in Amsterdam, which for decades has highlighted the Dutch resistance against Nazi terror during World War II, recently put on display dozens of vignettes meant to show more perspectives on the war, including those of the perpetrators. The exhibition has touched a nerve in the Netherlands, The Times’s Nina Siegal writes.
“We show pictures of some Nazis, especially Dutch Nazis,” the museum’s director said, “because they are also part of our history. The bad sides of history also have to be included.”
But some visitors, including survivors of the Holocaust, are upset to see the Nazis’ stories alongside those of murdered Dutch Jews. By treating every person as a fallible human, a descendant of one resister said, “the whole wartime disappears into a grayish state.”
